Share
Related Products
Low-Carb Magic for Happier Hormones Recipe Book (digital)
The Ongoing Debate
Carbs vs. Calories: What's More Important for Weight Management and Health?
When it comes to weight management and overall health, the debate between cutting carbs and calorie restriction has been ongoing for years. Which one is more effective for shedding pounds and staying healthy? Let's explore the approaches, the science behind them, and which one might work better for you.
Calories: The Energy Balance Theory
Calories are units of energy, and the traditional model of weight loss revolves around "calories in versus calories out." This theory suggests that consuming fewer calories than you burn results in weight loss, while a calorie surplus causes weight gain.
Studies consistently show that caloric restriction—eating fewer calories than you burn—can effectively lead to weight loss. However, adherence can be challenging, and long-term success may vary. In one study, participants following daily calorie restrictions experienced modest weight loss (around 5-10%) over 26 weeks. Maintaining this weight loss, though, requires continuous effort, highlighting the difficulty of sustaining purely calorie-based diets in the long term.
Why People Focus on Calories:
1. Simple Math: You lose weight if you eat fewer calories than your body needs.
2. All Foods Fit: You can eat anything as long as you stay within your calorie limit (it does not feel restricted to some).
3. Proven Results: Studies show calorie reduction helps with weight loss over time.
However, not all calories are created equal. 100 calories of sugary snacks affect your body differently than 100 calories of nutrient-dense foods like vegetables or protein. This brings us to the importance of the *quality* of what you eat, not just the quantity.
Carbs: The Insulin and Hormonal Perspective
Carbs are a primary energy source for your body, but not all carbohydrates are equal. Refined carbs (like white bread and sugary snacks) spike blood sugar levels, leading to a surge in insulin—your body's fat-storage hormone. Low-carb diets like keto have grown in popularity for their ability to stabilise insulin levels and promote fat-burning.
Research also points to the benefits of carbohydrate reduction, especially for managing insulin levels and improving metabolic health. Low-carbohydrate diets help stabilise blood sugar, promote fat-burning (through ketosis), and reduce cravings, particularly among individuals with insulin resistance or metabolic syndrome. A 12-week trial comparing low-carb and calorie-restricted diets found both effective, though low-carb regimens offered additional metabolic benefits, such as better insulin sensitivity and fat loss.
Focusing on eating a low-carb rather than a low-calorie diet throughout perimenopause, menopause, and beyond has helped many women improve their health and hormonal experience.
Why People Focus on Carbs:
1. Blood Sugar Control: Reducing carbs helps manage blood sugar and prevents insulin spikes.
2. Less Hunger: Protein and fat are more satiating, so people often feel fuller on a low-carb diet (especially if they consume fibre).
3. Fat-Burning Mode: When carbs are reduced, your body switches to burning fat for energy (ketosis).
4. Hormonal Health: Stable blood sugar supports hormone balance, critical for women with perimenopause and menopause symptoms.
Which One Should You Focus On for Weight Loss and Health?
The truth is that calories and carbs matter, but focusing on carb quality and overall nutrition yields better results for long-term health and sustainable weight management. Here's why:
- Not all Calories are Equal: Calories from sugary foods may contribute to weight gain and health issues, whereas calories from healthy fats and proteins help build muscle, reduce hunger, and support hormone health.
- Blood Sugar Stability is Key: Reducing blood sugar through carb control (especially refined carbs) prevents insulin spikes and fat storage. This is crucial for anyone struggling with energy crashes, mood swings, or hormone imbalances.
- Low-Carb = Fewer Cravings: High-carb diets can leave you hungry and craving more sugar, while a low-carb, high-fat diet promotes satiety and reduces mindless snacking.
- Calories Still Count: Even on a low-carb diet, eating too many calories from any source can stall weight loss. The goal is to find a healthy balance between calories and carbs.
What Should You Focus on for Weight Loss?
1. Prioritise Nutrient-Dense Foods: Focus on whole foods like lean proteins, healthy fats, and fibre-rich vegetables.
2. Watch Carbohydrate Quality: Choose complex carbs like sweet potatoes, carrots, quinoa, blueberries, strawberries, or leafy greens, and avoid processed sugars and refined grains.
3. Monitor Your Caloric Intake: While not obsessing over calories, being mindful of portion sizes will help prevent overeating.
4. Listen to Your Body: Everyone's body responds differently. Some people do well on low-carb diets, while others need more carbs to feel energised and balanced.
Intermittent Fasting and Continuous Calorie Restriction Comparison
Another study compared intermittent fasting (IF) with continuous calorie restriction (CCR) and found that both methods yielded significant weight loss, though IF showed slightly better outcomes in fat reduction. Notably, there was no meaningful difference in BMI changes between the two, indicating that the overall energy intake reduction, regardless of the approach, was the driving factor for weight loss.
Final Thoughts
The ideal approach to weight loss and health isn't about choosing between carbs or calories but finding what works for you. For many, managing carbohydrate intake helps with hormone balance, blood sugar stability, and reduced cravings, especially during perimenopause and menopause. At the same time, being aware of your total calorie intake ensures that you're not over-consuming, even with healthy foods.
Ultimately, the best weight management strategy feels sustainable, promotes long-term health, and aligns with your body's needs. By balancing the quality and quantity of your carbs and calories, you can achieve your weight and wellness goals effectively.
Ready to take control of your health?
Try incorporating the low-carb recipes from Low-Carb Magic for Happier Hormones into your routine for balanced blood sugar, hormone harmony, and sustainable weight management.
Resources:
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa022207
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa022637
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12640371/
https://academic.oup.com/lifemedi/article/1/2/58/6619300?login=false
Disclaimer: This article/post is for informational purposes only and should not be considered advice. One must seek proper professional advice from their trusted health practitioner.
